Five Stars! BookReview.com
The surprise and reward of reading is sometimes lost in the first hundred or so pages. Many books have readers slogging through one meaningless detail after another until reaching a dissatisfying ending. Thankfully, this novel is not one of those books... Holt interlocks an interesting dollop of crafty religio-mysticism and classic upper-class romance.

In their supremely positive visions, Holt (with words) and the protagonist (with a brush) paint warm strokes that relay a message of healing after loss. Not only does the protagonist's (Manhattan artisan Claire Lucas) radiant painting soften the hardest hearts but is a nod to the reader's sense of wonder and fertile imagination. Additionally, the story leans slightly on a Dan Brown-esque critique of religious status quo themes. But, thankfully, Brown's obsession with detail doesn't show up. Essentially, the story revolves around simpler themes of remorse and joy; loss and renewal; and embitterment and faith.

Holt presents an interesting concoction of romance and quasi-religious mystery that blends quite seamlessly. She has crafted a pleasantly surprising novel and a solid, quick read.


Foreword Magazine
The story carries from New York to Jerusalem, Glastonbury Tor to Siena in Italy. Holt shows a flair for descriptive detail, and has a good sense of when to shift backdrops.

 After the publishing tsunami which was The DaVinci Code, a mad rush ensued to put out the next Dan-Brown-style breakout—even Dan Brown tried—but nothing on that model has been equally commercial. The Painter’s Gift nods in that direction, but the place of religion in life is more practically divined here. The idea of piecing together a new holy message is appealing, the lead character is worth pulling for. This book should combine agreeably with a lawn chair, a beach towel, and a beverage of choice. 

Dr. Alex Pattakos, Bestselling Author of Prisoner of Our Thoughts
Frankly, I can't believe that this is Penelope Holt's first novel! It is truly an excellent, fascinating, and meaningful piece of work. "The Painter's Gift" not only reads well and holds your attention from start to finish, but also conveys a powerful message that "sticks" with the reader long after the adventure of reading it is completed. It is a "gift" for all just waiting to be unwrapped!

A Fabulous Read!
Reviewer: L. Kerber, Upton, Mass
"I loved this book!  It gets under your skin and drags you into some fascinating places--literal and figurative.  Very unique.  The kids were stuck in front of the TV, the dinner was burning and I couldn't put it down."
                                                                    
Loved It!
Reviewer: V. Daniels, Boston, Mass
"One of the best experiences I have had as a reader in a long time, and memorable.  Original and thought-provoking, the book stayed with me for days after I finished it.  You are a natural-born story teller.  Bring on the next yarn!"
                                                                         
Great Read! March 1,
Reviewer:    Barbara B. (Stratham, NH, USA)
A fast and most enjoyable read: I couldn't put this book down! Chock full of romance, mystery and international intrigue! The premise of the plot is fascinating and original. A real page-turner... you will be on the edge of your seat. Move over Dan Brown, for Penelope Holt!